FantasyPros Accuracy Award

2025 Accuracy Award Winner

Close FantasyPros Accuracy Award
Open Nav
Players
    Articles
      Shark Bites
        Show Navigation
        Show Menu
        FANTASY FOOTBALL NEWS

        Should We All Be Drafting Josh Reynolds Right Now?

        By Matt Schauf | Updated on Thu, Jul 3 2025 6:56 PM UTC
        Josh Reynolds Headshot

        We have Garrett Wilson projected for the 10th-most targets in our WR rankings. A key reason for that: The Jets' WR depth chart looks terrible behind him. That factor has apparently given Josh Reynolds a shot to make a real impact in what will be his ninth NFL season but first with New York.

        What They're Saying

        ESPN's Rich Cimini: "After a strong offseason, Reynolds is the clear-cut leader for the WR2 job. ... Beyond Garrett Wilson, the Jets lack big-play ability after cutting Davante Adams. Reynolds has separated from Allen Lazard and others."

        2025 Fantasy Football Impact

        Reynolds signed a one-year, $2.75 million contract on March 27. Those are terms and timing (more than two weeks after free agency opened) befitting a 30-year-old with just one season of more than 40 receptions.

        Reynolds' high points in targets (81), receptions (52), and receiving yards (618) all came back in 2020 with the Rams. He has exceeded 3 TDs in a season just twice. But Reynolds did post a 40-608-5 receiving line for the 2023 Lions.

        That team had new Jets HC Aaron Glenn as defensive coordinator. And new Jets OC Tanner Engstrand served as Detroit's passing-game coordinator.

        That Lions team also found no offensive teammate beating Reynolds' 15.2 yards per catch. Not ...

        • Jameson Williams (14.8)
        • Kalif Raymond (14.0)
        • or Amon-Ra St. Brown (12.7).

        Now, does any of that mean you should get excited about Reynolds this year? Not at all.

        The guy ranked 68th among WRs in PPR points per game in that aforementioned 2023 campaign. And his career-high points per game with those 2020 Rams landed Reynolds 87th at the position that year.

        Don't expect this veteran to be a factor in any but the deepest of redraft leagues. But there's another format in which he makes sense right now.

        Best Ball Impact

        This is where Reynolds makes sense, when you don't need to actively start him and can merely benefit the few times he scores a TD.

        He sits just 104th among WRs in best ball ADP as of this writing. That's well ahead of Lazard (WR124), but it also puts Reynolds in last-round range -- and means he often goes undrafted.

        Especially if you've got QB Justin Fields already rostered, consider using one of those final picks on the downfield guy who has already become the "clear-cut leader" at No. 2 WR for the Jets.

        Matt Schauf Author Image
        Matt Schauf, Editor
        Matt has earned two Fantasy Pros accuracy awards for IDP rankings and won thousands of dollars as a player across best ball, dynasty, and high-stakes fantasy formats. He has been creating fantasy football content for more than 20 years, with work featured by Sporting News, Rotoworld, Athlon, Sirius XM, and others. He's been with Draft Sharks since 2011.
        Fantasy Football Trade Targets: Buy a High-Ceiling WR Ahead of Week 2

        Fantasy Football Trade Targets: Buy a High-Ceiling WR Ahead of Week 2

        11:44am UTC 9/11/25

        Jameson Williams and the Lions got put to sleep in Week 1. Here's why you should buy him -- and two other potential stud WRs -- before they wake up.

        Read More »
        Week 2 Matchups That Matter: Perfect Bounce-Back Spot For Bengals

        Week 2 Matchups That Matter: Perfect Bounce-Back Spot For Bengals

        9:54am UTC 9/11/25

        A quick look at the most important matchup data to consider when making Week 2 start/sit decisions. Projected points, WR-CB matchup upgrades and downgrades, and more!

        Read More »
        Don’t Trust the Box Score: Rookie RB Was More Impressive Than His Stats

        Don’t Trust the Box Score: Rookie RB Was More Impressive Than His Stats

        5:53pm UTC 9/10/25

        The box score says one thing, but the film tells a different story. A rookie flashed, a vet proved he still has it, and a WR’s stats looked inflated.

        Read More »
        Money Back You have our personal money-back guarantee: If you’re not happy with our service for any reason, just reach out by December 31, 2025, and we’ll give you 100% of your subscription money back. No strings attached.  You can cancel with one-click from your account page anytime.
        Compare Plans » Compare Plans »