FantasyPros Accuracy Award

2025 Accuracy Award Winner

Close FantasyPros Accuracy Award
Open Nav
Players
    Articles
      Shark Bites
        Show Navigation
        Show Menu
        FANTASY FOOTBALL NEWS

        Michael Carter Owns Post-Trey Benson Backfield ... But Does He Deserve It?

        By Matt Schauf | Updated on Mon, Oct 6 2025 4:57 PM UTC
        Michael Carter Headshot

        Michael Carter led the Cardinals backfield Sunday in the first game since RB Trey Benson went down with a knee injury. Carter handled 18 of the 25 RB rushes in the Week 5 loss to the Titans. He also drew five of the team's six RB targets, tying Marvin Harrison Jr. for second on the team in that category. Carter caught all five of those to match TE Trey McBride for the team reception lead. But his yardage efficiency in both phases failed to impress.

        2025 Fantasy Football Impact

        Carter managed just 51 yards on his 18 carries (2.8 per rush) and 22 yards on his 5 receptions (4.4 per catch). He did deliver a 1-yard rushing TD early in the first quarter and ranks eighth among RBs in PPR points ahead of the Monday night game.

        But Carter also went for 1.72 yards under expectation per carry. That ranked third-worst for the week, according to NFL Next Gen Stats.

        Zonovan "Bam" Knight matched Carter's 2.8 yards per rush but edged him in yards after contact per carry and Pro Football Focus rushing grade. Knight carried just four times for the game, though, and logged one target among his 11 total snaps and five routes.

        Emari Demercado ranked second among the trio in playing time but drew just three carries and no targets, and committed about the stupidest play a guy can make.

        Carter's limited success plays especially poorly against a Tennessee defense that sits 29th in total DVOA and 31st against the run. But the guys behind him probably don't present enough juice to motivate a significant shift for Week 6.

        Expect Carter to crack the top 24 in our Week 6 RB rankings for a trip to Indianapolis. But the Colts and Packers the next two weeks both present negative RB-scoring matchups according to our strength of schedule.

        If you see a RB-needy manager in your league, consider shopping Carter off Sunday's fantasy total. Arizona's Week 8 bye follows those two games.

        Matt Schauf Author Image
        Matt Schauf, Editor
        Matt has earned two Fantasy Pros accuracy awards for IDP rankings and won thousands of dollars as a player across best ball, dynasty, and high-stakes fantasy formats. He has been creating fantasy football content for more than 20 years, with work featured by Sporting News, Rotoworld, Athlon, Sirius XM, and others. He's been with Draft Sharks since 2011.
        Week 5 Matchups That Matter: Fireworks From The Jets Offense?!

        Week 5 Matchups That Matter: Fireworks From The Jets Offense?!

        10:17am UTC 10/5/25

        A quick look at the most important matchup data to consider when making Week 5 start/sit decisions. Projected points, WR-CB matchup upgrades and downgrades, and more!

        Read More »
        Week 5 IDP Hits: Payton Wilson Might Make -- or Kill -- Your Season

        Week 5 IDP Hits: Payton Wilson Might Make -- or Kill -- Your Season

        6:52pm UTC 10/4/25

        The second-year Steeler LB followed an alarming Week 3 with a season-altering Week 4. Maybe. Can we count on him? Let's get into that and more IDP nuggets.

        Read More »
        Week 5 Wide Receiver Preview: Is Quentin Johnston a Must Start?

        Week 5 Wide Receiver Preview: Is Quentin Johnston a Must Start?

        4:49pm UTC 10/3/25

        From rookies in plus spots to vets with proven ceilings, these WRs have the matchups to rack up points in Week 5.

        Read More »
        Money Back You have our personal money-back guarantee: If you’re not happy with our service for any reason, just reach out by December 31, 2025, and we’ll give you 100% of your subscription money back. No strings attached.  You can cancel with one-click from your account page anytime.
        Compare Plans » Compare Plans »