FantasyPros Accuracy Award

2025 Accuracy Award Winner

Close FantasyPros Accuracy Award
Open Nav
Players
    Articles
      Shark Bites
        Show Navigation
        Show Menu

        Juice Up Your Backfield: Our Data-Driven RB Handcuff Rankings

        Not all handcuffs are created equal. We ranked all 32 backup RBs by talent, opportunity, and offense so you know who’s worth a stash and who’s just dead weight.
        By Jared Smola | Updated on Sun, Aug 24 2025 5:55 PM UTC
        Juice Up Your Backfield: Our Data-Driven RB Handcuff Rankings

        Nailing the Best RB Handcuffs Can Supercharge Your Fantasy Season

        RB fantasy production is incredibly volume-driven. A backup RB can often produce 80%, 90%, or even 100% of the starter’s fantasy points on the same workload. (Shoutout to the “RBs don’t matter” crowd.)

        And therein lies the power of RB handcuffs.

         

        How Do We Find the Best RB Handcuffs in 2025?

        This is not your typical article on the best RB handcuffs. We’re not arbitrarily ranking the backups based on gut feel. We’re taking a more methodical approach to pinpointing the top handcuffs to target in your fantasy draft.

        Let’s start by defining what makes a top handcuff. The ideal handcuff:

        1. Is talented
        2. Is the clear No. 2 RB on his team
        3. Plays in a strong offense
        4. Is backing up a high-risk starter

        Let’s score each handcuff on a scale of 1-10 in each of those categories. We’ll then average those scores to come up with handcuff rankings.

        NOTE

        These are strictly handcuff rankings. We’re not taking into account any standalone value these RBs might have. For rankings that consider both standalone value and handcuff upside in YOUR fantasy league, get this custom fantasy football cheatsheet.

         

        Best RB Handcuffs, Ranked 1-32

        RankPlayer Team Talent Depth chartoffense strengthstarter riskhandcuff score
        1Zach Charbonnet SEA 9 10487.75
        2Ray DavisBUF781057.5
        3Trey BensonARI69687.25
        t-4Tyjae Spears TEN 8 10366.75
        t-4Rachaad WhiteTB75966.75
        6Tyler AllgeierATL810446.5
        t-7Brian RobinsonSF63886.25
        t-7Cam SkatteboNYG68296.25
        t-7Nick ChubbHOU465106.25
        t-7Kareem HuntKC35986.25
        t-7Will ShipleyPHI56956.25
        t-12Bhayshul Tuten *JAC75576.0
        t-12Chris Rodriguez *WAS45966.0
        t-14Braelon AllenNYJ78265.75
        t-14Rico DowdleCAR67465.75
        t-14Tahj BrooksCIN46765.75
        t-14Najee HarrisLAC75655.75
        t-14Kendre MillerNO67285.75
        t-19Blake CorumLAR55755.5
        t-19MarShawn LloydGB64755.5
        t-19Justice HillBAL541035.5
        t-22Miles SandersDAL34595.25
        t-22Roschon JohnsonCHI63575.25
        t-22D.J. GiddensIND56465.25
        t-22Ollie GordonMIA63575.25
        26Dylan SampsonCLE55174.5
        27Craig Reynolds *DET32934.25
        28Zamir WhiteLV45344.0
        t-29Antonio Gibson *NE43443.75
        t-29Kenneth Gainwell *PIT43443.75
        t-31Ty Chandler *MIN42533.5
        t-31Jaleel McLaughlin *DEN32633.5

        Note: Players marked with a * are third on their team's depth chart behind a committee. This has been factored into their Depth Chart and Starter Risk scores.

         

        Top 5 Handcuffs For 2025

        1. Zach Charbonnet, Seattle Seahawks

        Headshot of Zach Charbonnet

        Charbonnet is perhaps the most proven handcuff in fantasy football. Here were his finishes among RBs in PPR points in six games without RB Ken Walker last year:

        • 8th
        • 7th
        • 1st
        • 17th
        • 20th
        • 39th

        Charbonnet has enough talent to start for many NFL teams, and there's no threat behind him on the depth chart. Walker, meanwhile, has missed 10 games through three NFL seasons and has dealt with foot soreness throughout August.

         

        2. Ray Davis, Buffalo Bills

        Headshot of Ray Davis

        We've seen Davis produce big fantasy numbers as a handcuff. When RB James Cook missed Week 6 last year, Davis racked up 152 total yards on 23 touches against a good Jets defense. He finished 12th among RBs in PPR points that week, despite not scoring a TD.

        This is a talented player locked in as the No. 2 RB on a Bills offense implied for the most points in the league this season. His Depth Chart score takes a slight hit only because he'd lose some passing-down snaps to RB Ty Johnson if Cook misses time.

        TIP

        For more on Davis, check out 2025 Fantasy Football Sleepers.

          

        3. Trey Benson, Arizona Cardinals

        Headshot of Trey Benson

        There's no glaring weakness to Benson's handcuff profile.

        He's playing behind one of the biggest injury risks at the position in James Conner, who has missed at least one game in all eight of his NFL seasons. Benson plays on an above-average offense with no threat to lead duties if Conner goes down again. And he's a nice talent, averaging 4.6 yards per carry as a third-round rookie last year.

        Don't expect Benson to be a fantasy factor when Conner is healthy. But he's a solid bet to get spot starts this season and produce as at least a RB2.

         

        t-4. Tyjae Spears, Tennessee Titans

        Headshot of Tyjae Spears

        Spears suffered a high-ankle sprain on August 9 that has him iffy for the start of the season. Once he's healthy, though, he'll be locked in as the No. 2 RB behind Tony Pollard. RBs Julius Chestnut and Kalel Mullings are not threats.

        When Pollard missed Week 17 last year, Spears racked up 103 total yards on 23 touches -- despite leaving that game early with a concussion.

        This is an electric runner and talented receiver who would play a three-down role if Pollard misses time again this season.

           

        t-4. Rachaad White, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

        Headshot of Rachaad White

        Bucky Irving emerged as the biggest talent and the lead back in Tampa Bay last season. But White also turned in a nice campaign.

        He set career highs in:

        • Yards per carry
        • Yards after contact per attempt
        • Rush yards over expected per attempt
        • Pro Football Focus rushing grade

        White ranked top-28 in all four metrics among 47 qualifying RBs league wide. He's a capable runner and a plus pass catcher, with the fourth-most receptions among RBs over the last three seasons.

        Sean Tucker would certainly be part of the attack if Irving misses time this year. But White would get plenty of rushing volume and control pass-catching work. On a Bucs offense implied for the seventh-most points, that'd be more than enough to make White a strong fantasy starter.

            

        Don't Miss 2025's Best RB Handcuffs

        The Draft War Room marks handcuff targets with an icon, so you never miss a potential league-winner again.

        The best RB handcuffs are marked with an icon on your Draft War Room.

        Get the most dynamic cheat sheet in fantasy football, powered by live-draft sync.

        Create your Draft War Room now.

         

        Learn more about the Draft War Room in the video below:

         

        Jared Smola Author Image
        Jared Smola, Lead Analyst
        Jared has been with Draft Sharks since 2007. He’s now Lead Analyst, heading up the preseason and weekly projections that fuel your Draft War Room and in-season tools. He currently ranks ninth among 173 analysts in draft rankings accuracy.
        Other rankings are stale  before the 2nd round.

        Draft using the best dynamic tool in the industry. Our fantasy player valuations (3D Values) change during your draft in response to...

        1. Exact league settings - direct sync
        2. Opponent and Team Needs
        3. Positional scarcity & available players
        4. Ceiling, injury risk, ADP, and more!

        You need a dynamic cheat sheet that easily live-syncs with your draft board and adapts throughout your draft using 17 crucial indicators.

        Get your Draft War Room Today
        Winning Your League Starts Here
        Money Back You have our personal money-back guarantee: If you’re not happy with our service for any reason, just reach out by December 31, 2025, and we’ll give you 100% of your subscription money back. No strings attached.  You can cancel with one-click from your account page anytime.
        Compare Plans » Compare Plans »