FantasyPros Accuracy Award

2025 Accuracy Award Winner

Close FantasyPros Accuracy Award
Open Nav
Players
    Articles
      Shark Bites
        Show Navigation
        Show Menu

        In This Article

        Matthew Stafford
        LAR QB
        Open player page
        Philip Rivers
        IND QB
        Open player page
        Aaron Rodgers
        PIT QB
        Open player page
        Jared Goff
        DET QB
        Open player page
        Dak Prescott
        DAL QB
        Open player page
        Jacoby Brissett
        ARI QB
        Open player page
        Baker Mayfield
        TB QB
        Open player page
        Josh Allen
        BUF QB
        Open player page
        Joe Burrow
        CIN QB
        Open player page
        Justin Herbert
        LAC QB
        Open player page
        Jalen Hurts
        PHI QB
        Open player page
        Trevor Lawrence
        JAC QB
        Open player page
        Tyler Huntley
        BAL QB
        Open player page
        Malik Willis
        GB QB
        Open player page
        Brock Purdy
        SF QB
        Open player page
        C.J. Stroud
        HOU QB
        Open player page
        Bryce Young
        CAR QB
        Open player page
        Drake Maye
        NE QB
        Open player page
        Caleb Williams
        CHI QB
        Open player page
        Bo Nix
        DEN QB
        Open player page
        Cameron Ward
        TEN QB
        Open player page
        Jaxson Dart
        NYG QB
        Open player page
        Tyler Shough
        NO QB
        Open player page

        Week 17 Quarterback Preview: Caleb Williams’ Risk Profile for Week 17 Lineups

        Williams enters Week 17 as a volatile fantasy play, especially with Chicago still banged up at WR. Get his risk profile, matchup notes vs. SF, and more. Plus, who else is playable beyond the top QBs?
        By Kevin English Updated on December 26, 2025 9:17 PM UTC
        Week 17 Quarterback Preview: Caleb Williams’ Risk Profile for Week 17 Lineups

        Top Fantasy QBs for Week 17

        Let's break down the key usage notes and matchups that are driving our Week 17 QB Rankings.

        TIP

        Get customized projections and start/sit advice for your quarterbacks with the Team Intel tool.

        1. Josh Allen, Buffalo Bills

        Headshot of Josh Allen
        Josh Allen Open player page

        QB1 on Sun 4:25 PM vs PHI

        Bye7
        Week 17 PPR Proj20.5
        Current Week-13.8

        Philly has proved capable of providing a difficult QB-scoring matchup. But they've also faced limited players/offenses in recent weeks: Commanders (with Marcus Mariota leaving early), Raiders (with Kenny Pickett), Chargers, Bears. The Week 12 visit to Dallas just before that stretch found Dak Prescott topping 30 fantasy points against the Eagles, the largest score they've allowed to the position all season. There's downside risk to Allen, especially with a foot issue limiting his practice reps this week. But there's also plenty of risk to betting against Allen, especially with his team still alive for the division title.

        2. Joe Burrow, Cincinnati Bengals

        Headshot of Joe Burrow
        Joe Burrow Open player page

        QB2 on Sun 1:00 PM vs ARI

        Bye10
        Week 17 PPR Proj20.4
        Current Week18.8%

        Burrow went off for 309-4 last week vs. Miami, giving him 22+ fantasy points in three of his past four outings. Now he draws an Arizona pass defense that could be without top DB Budda Baker (concussion).

        3. Drake Maye, New England Patriots

        Headshot of Drake Maye
        Drake Maye Open player page

        QB3 on Sun 1:00 PM @ NYJ

        Bye14
        Week 17 PPR Proj20.2
        Current Week2.6

        Maye hasn't reached the top 6 in weekly scoring since Week 8. But he hasn't finished lower than QB15 since and ranked top-12 in five of his past six games.

        4. Dak Prescott, Dallas Cowboys

        Headshot of Dak Prescott
        Dak Prescott Open player page

        QB4 on Thu 1:00 PM @ WAS

        Bye10
        Week 17 PPR Proj20.1
        Current Week48.2%

        (Played on Thursday)

        5. Trevor Lawrence, Jacksonville Jaguars

        Headshot of Trevor Lawrence
        Trevor Lawrence Open player page

        QB5 on Sun 1:00 PM @ IND

        Bye8
        Week 17 PPR Proj19.8
        Current Week6.0%

        Last week looked like it should have been a challenging spot for Lawrence (at Denver), but he racked up QB2-overall numbers. That marked five straight top-12 finishes and his second straight top-2. Lawrence certainly belongs in your lineup against a Colts D that just allowed 48 points to the Niners.

        6. Brock Purdy, San Francisco 49ers
        Headshot of Brock Purdy

        Brock Purdy Open player page

        QB6 on Sun 8:20 PM vs CHI

        Bye14
        Week 17 PPR Proj19.5
        Current Week8.2%

        Purdy dominated the Colts last week. He went 25/34 for 295 yards and 5 TDs through the air. He had a late INT, but it didn’t hinder Purdy’s day. The one downside this week is that TE George Kittle could sit out. Still, Purdy tears up two-deep defenses like the Bears, so it remains a strong fantasy spot.

        7. Matthew Stafford, Los Angeles Rams

        Headshot of Matthew Stafford
        Matthew Stafford Open player page

        QB7 on Mon 8:15 PM @ ATL

        Bye8
        Week 17 PPR Proj19.5
        Current Week-3.7%

        No Davante Adams? Tough Seahawks defense? Windy conditions? Didn't matter. Stafford exploded for a huge 457-yard, three-TD outing last week. He's now tossed multiple scores in nine straight games. Even with Adams out again this week, Stafford is a strong fantasy start against a slumping Falcons defense that ranks 21st in adjusted fantasy points allowed to QBs over the last five weeks.

        8. Jalen Hurts, Philadelphia Eagles

        Headshot of Jalen Hurts
        Jalen Hurts Open player page

        QB8 on Sun 4:25 PM @ BUF

        Bye9
        Week 17 PPR Proj19.1
        Current Week-24.0%

        Hurts has delivered two straight weeks of efficient production -- 75.6% completions, 8.0 yards per attempt, 11.1% TD rate -- with good rushing numbers as well. He gets a challenge from a Buffalo D that's been ninth-toughest on QB scoring for the year. Hurts remains a solid play, but the downside risk pushes him lower in QB1 territory.

        9. Caleb Williams, Chicago Bears

        Headshot of Caleb Williams
        Caleb Williams Open player page

        QB9 on Sun 8:20 PM @ SF

        Bye5
        Week 17 PPR Proj18.9
        Current Week9.4%

        Williams went 19/34 for 250 yards and 2 TDs last week, with most of that coming toward the end of the game. He also added 30 rushing yards. Williams’ volatility makes him tough to trust, but he continues adding rushing to bump his fantasy points. WR Luther Burden could return and help Williams’ fantasy potential as well. Add in shootout potential, and the second-year pro ranks as a low-end QB1.

        10. Jacoby Brissett, Arizona Cardinals
        Headshot of Jacoby Brissett

        Jacoby Brissett Open player page

        QB10 on Sun 1:00 PM @ CIN

        Bye8
        Week 17 PPR Proj18.9
        Current Week-0.9%

        Brissett’s streak of nine-straight top-12 fantasy finishes ended last week vs. Atlanta. The good news? He draws a nice matchup this Sunday vs. the Bengals, one that has the Cardinals implied for a decent 22.5 points as 7.5-point underdogs.

        11. Baker Mayfield, Tampa Bay Buccaneers

        Headshot of Baker Mayfield
        Baker Mayfield Open player page

        QB11 on Sun 1:00 PM @ MIA

        Bye9
        Week 17 PPR Proj18.7
        Current Week19.7%

        The Dolphins have allowed at least 18 fantasy points to opposing QBs in all but one game. (The lone exception came against Brady Cook and the Jets.) Mayfield has struggled in the second half of the season, hitting 18 fantasy points in only three of his past nine games. But with Tampa Bay's pass catchers healthy, Mayfield will garner a look as a fringe QB1.

        12. Bo Nix, Denver Broncos

        Headshot of Bo Nix
        Bo Nix Open player page

        QB12 on Thu 8:15 PM @ KC

        Bye12
        Week 17 PPR Proj18.6
        Current Week-10.0%

        (Played on Thursday)

        13. Tyler Shough, New Orleans Saints

        Headshot of Tyler Shough
        Tyler Shough Open player page

        QB13 on Sun 1:00 PM @ TEN

        Bye11
        Week 17 PPR Proj18.2
        Current Week-18.4%

        Shough has finished as a top-19 fantasy QB in six straight games, with three top-13 finishes. He's in a nice spot this weekend against a Titans defense that's much tougher against the run than the pass. Tennessee ranks 25th in adjusted fantasy points allowed to QBs on the season -- and 29th over the last five weeks. Expect another voluminous and productive outing from Shough on Sunday.

        14. Jared Goff, Detroit Lions

        (Played on Thursday

        15. Jaxson Dart, New York Giants

        Headshot of Jaxson Dart
        Jaxson Dart Open player page

        QB15 on Sun 4:05 PM @ LVR

        Bye14
        Week 17 PPR Proj17.5
        Current Week10.7%

        Dart crashed last week against a surging Minnesota defense, but this week's matchup versus the Raiders looks more favorable. Las Vegas has allowed the 13th-most schedule-adjusted fantasy points to QBs. Before last week, Dart averaged 211 passing yards per game in his previous 8 starts, with 43.2 yards per game on the ground. The Raiders allow 209.7 passing yards per game, so 210 passing yards and 30-plus rushing yards is reasonable. Dart is a mid-range QB2 with top-12 upside thanks to his rushing ability.

        16. Sam Darnold, Seattle Seahawks

        Headshot of Sam Darnold
        Sam Darnold Open player page

        QB16 on Sun 1:00 PM @ CAR

        Bye8
        Week 17 PPR Proj17.3
        Current Week-8.2

        Darnold has multiple TD strikes in 5 of his 7 road games this season, but travels to Carolina to face a Panthers' defense that has played well. Carolina has allowed the eighth-fewest fantasy points to QBs, including just 18 TD passes allowed. However, 12 of the 18 have come in Carolina, so Darnold should be considered a mid-range QB2 with decent TD potential.

        17. Malik Willis, Green Bay Packers

        Headshot of Malik Willis
        Malik Willis Open player page

        QB17 on Sat 8:00 PM vs BAL

        Bye5
        Week 17 PPR Proj16.6
        Current Week-9.2%

        Willis is squarely on the superflex radar if he starts Saturday night's game vs. the Ravens. He played well in relief of QB Jordan Love (concussion) last weekend, completing 9 of 11 passes for 121 yards and a TD. He picked up another 44 yards on 10 carries. Willis also impressed in two starts last year, totaling 324 yards and two TDs passing and 114 yards and a score on the ground. He finished those weeks QB22 and QB6 in fantasy points.

        18. C.J. Stroud, Houston Texans

        Headshot of C.J. Stroud
        C.J. Stroud Open player page

        QB18 on Sat 4:30 PM @ LAC

        Bye6
        Week 17 PPR Proj16.2
        Current Week-32.0%

        Stroud managed just 187 yards and a TD on 35 pass attempts against the weak Raiders defense. That marked his third finish of QB18 or worse in four games since returning from injury. Stroud's a poor play this week against a Chargers D that's been fourth-toughest on QB scoring.

        19. Justin Herbert, Los Angeles Chargers
        Headshot of Justin Herbert

        Justin Herbert Open player page

        QB19 on Sat 4:30 PM vs HOU

        Bye12
        Week 17 PPR Proj15.9
        Current Week-23.7%

        Herbert might be tough to sit off a top-5 fantasy score against Dallas. But this week's matchup looks near-opposite. Whereas the Cowboys have allowed the league's most QB fantasy points, Houston's been stingy. The Texans have yielded a mere 17 passes across 15 games, while snagging 16 INTs.

        20. Kirk Cousins, Atlanta Falcons

        Headshot of Kirk Cousins
        Kirk Cousins Open player page

        QB20 on Mon 8:15 PM vs LAR

        Bye5
        Week 17 PPR Proj15.6
        Current Week3.2%

        Cousins has played reasonably well the past two weeks and turned in QB4 and QB9 fantasy finishes. There's some shootout potential in Monday night's home game against a slumping Rams defense that ranks 23rd in adjusted fantasy points allowed to QBs over the last five weeks. Cousins makes sense in superflex lineups, but we still wouldn't want to trust the 37-year-old as a QB1.

        21. Bryce Young, Carolina Panthers

        Headshot of Bryce Young
        Bryce Young Open player page

        QB21 on Sun 1:00 PM vs SEA

        Bye14
        Week 17 PPR Proj15.3
        Current Week-16.0%

        This is a below-average matchup for Young and the Panthers. Seattle has allowed the ninth-fewest fantasy points to QBs. In seven road games, the Seahawks have surrendered just 8 total TD passes. Meanwhile, Young has thrown for under 200 yards in 11 of his 14 starts. Carolina's implied total of 17.5 points is the fourth-lowest for Week 17 and indicates another low-ceiling game for Young. He's a QB2 with limited upside.

        22. Tyler Huntley, Baltimore Ravens

        Headshot of Tyler Huntley
        Tyler Huntley Open player page

        QB22 on Sat 8:00 PM @ GB

        Bye7
        Week 17 PPR Proj15.2
        Current Week3.8%

        Huntley has averaged 7.6 carries for 39.4 yards and 0.31 TDs across 13 full NFL games, putting him on the superflex radar. Just don't expect much in the way of passing. He's averaged 171 yards and 0.6 TDs through the air in those 13 games. Saturday night brings a tough spot in Green Bay against the Packers' 11th-ranked QB defense.

        23. Philip Rivers, Indianapolis Colts

        Headshot of Philip Rivers
        Philip Rivers Open player page

        QB23 on Sun 1:00 PM vs JAC

        Bye11
        Week 17 PPR Proj15.1
        Current Week-1.0%

        Rivers catapulted to a QB13 finish in his second game back, thanks largely to a bad San Francisco defense. Now comes a Jacksonville D that ranks eighth in total defensive DVOA and ninth against the pass.

        24. Aaron Rodgers, Pittsburgh Steelers

        Headshot of Aaron Rodgers
        Aaron Rodgers Open player page

        QB24 on Sun 1:00 PM @ CLE

        Bye5
        Week 17 PPR Proj14.7
        Current Week20.0%

        Rodgers has been surprisingly consistent lately. He has 15+ fantasy points in each of the last three weeks. The Steelers offense is heating up, but without DK Metcalf this week, it will be tough to trust Rodgers. He went 21/30 for 235 and 2 TDs in Week 6 against the Browns, finishing as QB16. The Browns have only allowed two top-12 QB scoring weeks this year, so Rodgers is a QB2 only for Superflex leagues.

        25. Cam Ward, Tennessee Titans

        Headshot of Cameron Ward
        Cameron Ward Open player page

        QB25 on Sun 1:00 PM vs NO

        Bye10
        Week 17 PPR Proj14.7
        Current Week11.9%

        Ward is putting together a promising finish to his rookie season. He's tossed two scores in three straight games, has set season highs in adjusted yards per attempt in two straight, and posted season highs in completion rate and yards per attempt last week. He's still finished just QB19, QB23, and QB14 in fantasy points the last three weeks, though, and remains a low-end QB2 against an underrated Saints defense.

        Kevin English Author Image
        Kevin English, Senior Analyst
        Kevin brings 15+ years of experience as a fantasy analyst and mid-stakes competitor across various formats (redraft, best ball, dynasty, DFS). He finished 1st in FantasyPros Draft Accuracy competition in 2024. Kevin's work has been featured in The Mercury News, NBC Sports/Rotoworld, and FantasyPros.
        Other rankings are stale  before the 2nd round.

        Draft using the best dynamic tool in the industry. Our fantasy player valuations (3D Values) change during your draft in response to...

        1. Exact league settings - direct sync
        2. Opponent and Team Needs
        3. Positional scarcity & available players
        4. Ceiling, injury risk, ADP, and more!

        You need a dynamic cheat sheet that easily live-syncs with your draft board and adapts throughout your draft using 17 crucial indicators.

        Get your Draft War Room Today
        Winning Your League Starts Here
        Money Back You have our personal money-back guarantee: If you’re not happy with our service for any reason, just reach out by December 31, 2026, and we’ll give you 100% of your subscription money back. No strings attached.  You can cancel with one-click from your account page anytime.